While there were at times a single "great chief" acknowledged by the others, it was not a formal position and didn't change the fact that the Comanches governed themselves via a council where representatives had a vote, not any sort of monarchy. These bands would then combine informally into a tribe or nation, but this was based on mutual need or advantage.Ĭomanche government was therefore very council-based, with elders gathering on a formal and informal basis to discuss issues and come to decisions. Sometimes these bands could be hundreds strong, and the elder patriarch was usually referred to as a chief. As historian Thomas Kavanagh explains, the Comanche Nation was divided into "bands," which were centered on a patriarch and usually comprised of extended relatives. Here's the secret story of the Comanche: The most powerful Native American tribe in history.ĭespite having a few famous Chiefs of their own, the Comanches were not this organized or unified. They were only defeated in the late 19 th century, and that defeat required more than American soldiers to bring about.
They once controlled a vast empire in the heartland of what would become parts of Colorado, Kansas, Oklahoma, New Mexico, and Texas, and they held off invaders for decades. This Native American nation was once the most powerful in America-and one of the most effective fighting forces in history, hands down. The Native Americans who found themselves fighting for their lives against the United States were diverse, representing many thriving and complex civilizations-and they were more effective at fighting an endless war against impossible odds than you might think.Ĭase in point: The Comanches. As I watched the hand to hand sequences I as astonished by the realization that I had seen all of this material before and even the names of techniques.
Even when the violence and brutality of America's tactics are acknowledged, there is usually still the assumption that the Native American civilizations we conquered never stood a chance.īut pull on any thread in that narrative and it falls apart. As a martial artist and someone who is interested in primitive skills and Native American lore and culture I jumped at the chance to watch the video 'Indian Fighting Skills' by Randall Brown. It's a story of brutally inevitable conquest, of an advanced nation hungry for territory overpowering a weak coalition of indigenous people who are often portrayed as ignorant and even savage. in the scout class of his tracker school.For many Americans, the story of how we conquered the continent is a straightforward one. the stealth technique taught is the same as the "scout step" taught by Tom Brown Jr. The exercises are also interesting but common to Systema, catch wrestling, circus, carnival, and other arts. however the video is visually interesting. I do not think the information is historically accurate and don't find much of it to be very practical. Please note that these are just my opinions based of what I saw on the video and my study of these cultures. Brown's discussion of Plains indian culture to contradict itself and the academic research of experts like Thomas E. Brown refered to the practice from the first person present tense, "we do" instead of the third person past tense of a historical survey, "they did". I found it odd that during the lecture portion of the video Mr.
#COMBAT STYLE AMERICAN INDIAN DVD MOVIE#
This is not to mention that much of the war club and tomahawk sequences were identical to those in the movie "Last of the Mohicans" from 1992. some of them as well as some of the weapons techniques were identical to techniques found on the Panther Productions "Robert Bussey: Ninja Master Series". The street combat variations also seemed familiar.
#COMBAT STYLE AMERICAN INDIAN DVD PRO#
much of the skills demonstrated were identical to Professional wrestling and have the same names as pro wrestling moves. As a martial artist and someone who is interested in primitive skills and Native American lore and culture I jumped at the chance to watch the video "Indian Fighting Skills" by Randall Brown.Īs I watched the hand to hand sequences I as astonished by the realization that I had seen all of this material before and even the names of techniques were familiar.
0 kommentar(er)
